Click here to learn about Mt. Olive’s response to COVID-19



Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers

Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers

( 2 customer reviews )

Like sweet and salty pickles on your sandwich? These sandwich stuffer pickles are sliced flat for sandwich satisfaction with Mt. Olive’s signature sweet Bread & Butter pickle flavor!

Available as:
Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers (16 oz.) – 09300 00067
Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers w/Sea Salt (24 oz.) – 09300 00655
No Sugar Added Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers (16 oz.) – 09300 00112
Simply Pickles Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers (16 oz.) – 09300 00530

Find In Store
SKU: 0930000067 Categories: , Tag:



Are you ready to take your sandwich game up a notch or two? At Mt. Olive we have the perfect way to transform your ho-hum Sammy into something amazing. Try adding our Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers to your next sandwich and you will never look at your Turkey sandwich the same.

Our tangy Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers are sliced perfectly to simply slide onto any sandwich. What sandwiches do we recommend you try them on? Anything on Rye bread goes great with our Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers. Try our addicting flavor with your favorite sandwich recipes. Chicken sandwiches, Sloppy Joe’s, a grilled sandwich like grilled cheese, ham and cheese, keep it simple with an avocado sandwich, a tuna sandwich, all your sandwich favorites can get the wow they need with Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers.

Next time you have a burger, hold the ketchup and add our Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers. It will give your burger that bit of zesty flavor it needs and help to keep things moist and juicy thanks to that flavorful pickle juice. They are also great with pulled pork sliders.

There are so many ways to enjoy the Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers. Try them on your next steak sandwich, you get the idea, there is not a sandwich on earth that cannot benefit from the sweet tangy flavor.

It’s a Historical Taste

Most people are not aware but bread and butter pickles, got their name because during the Great Depression people would stuff these pickles between two slices of bread and butter.  Get it? Stuffed between bread and butter?

Today, most people have moved away from the bread and butter and pickle sandwiches, although if you have a hankering for it we celebrate you for staying true to the foundation of bread butter and pickles. Bread and butter pickles have always been a welcome accompaniment to the lowly sandwich.

Packed With Flavor

Like all of our other pickle products, we use the freshest ingredients like cukes from North Carolina growers. We use the ingredients in our ready to eat pickles that you would use if they were homemade pickles.

Ingredients like ground turmeric, onion, garlic powder from fresh cloves, granulated sugar, celery seeds, paprika, mustard seed, red pepper flakes, fresh dill, and teaspoons of all the good things that make our pickle recipe a family favorite. Once everything is deliciously combined we slice them to ensure they fit perfectly in your sandwich.

We create the store-bought pickles that taste just like home. At Mt. Olive every pickle that we produce goes through the highest quality standards. We are full of pickle pride.

Gluten-Free, No Fat, Low Calorie

Watching your weight? You can cut back on the condiments and add Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers to your sandwich instead. They are a gluten-free, fat-free option that will dress any sandwich perfectly. Of course, we won’t judge you if you prefer to eat them right out of the jar. We can’t say we blame you.

Get Your Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers at your favorite grocery store. Try all our great pickle products including our dill chips, bread & butter chips, sweet gherkins, kosher dill chips, dill spears and more.

Reviews (2)

2 reviews for Bread & Butter Sandwich Stuffers

  1. Benjamin Francis Cooley

    Best on the market. These are so good, I like to eat them with just a hint of mayo on the bread as a sandwich. FANTASTIC!

  2. Peggy Brady

    I really enjoy eating your pickles but my favorite type is the bread and butter pickles. I just can’t find a large enough jar. I live in Hattiesburg MS. When I travel to Colorado and Texas I am always looking for your pickles. in a larger jar. I love your pickles.

Add a review